Vaping News

The Misguided Prohibitionist Agenda

CAPHRA says it is unveiling the truth about the misguided prohibitionist agenda being promoted by New Zealand’s Public Health Collaboration Council

Share on:

In a bold response to recent publications by the Public Health Collaboration Council (, Nancy Loucas, the Executive Coordinator of the Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA), has called out what she describes as a "covert prohibitionist agenda" that prioritises rhetoric over science in the debate over oral tobacco and nicotine products. 

Loucas, a seasoned public health policy expert, has criticised PHCC for its one-sided portrayal of oral tobacco and nicotine products as a gateway to teen addiction, while ignoring their potential as harm reduction tools for adult who smoker.  

"It's time to correct the narrative and focus on evidence-based solutions that respect the autonomy and rights of individuals to make informed choices about their health," said Loucas. 

 CAPHRA's stance is that PHCC’s approach is steeped in a prohibitionist ideology, which Loucas refers to as "philanthropic colonialism." The disinformation being promoted is part of a global “script” that promotes a narrative that does not focus on science and fact, but instead the imposition of Western-centric health policies without proper consideration for local contexts or scientific evidence.  

"Such an approach is not only paternalistic but also detrimental to the development of effective public health strategies," Loucas added. 

Loucas has also highlighted concerns about PHCC’s alignment with the WHO, suggesting that this may come at the expense of scientific integrity.  

"Aligning with the WHO should not mean selling out on science. We need policies that are informed by the latest research, not by the desire for international recognition," Loucas emphasised. 

CAPHRA is advocating for a re-evaluation of PHCC's stance on oral tobacco and nicotine products, urging for policies that are balanced and rooted in scientific evidence. 

"Public health policies should protect youth while also providing adults who smoke with access to safer alternatives. It's not an either-or situation; we can and must do both, as New Zealand is an example used in the wider Asia Pacific region for pragmatism and fairness in policy," Loucas stated. 

CAPHRA is committed to promoting harm reduction and ensuring that public health policies are guided by science, not ideology. The organisation calls for a transparent and inclusive dialogue that considers all stakeholders, including consumers, in the development of effective strategies to combat smoking-related harm. 

It’s sad that both the WHO and PHCC seems not to understand this,” Loucas said. 

The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Advocates is a regional alliance of consumer tobacco harm reduction advocacy organisations. Its mission is to educate, advocate and represent the right of adult alternative nicotine consumers to access and use of products that reduce harm from tobacco use.

CAPHRA says it remains committed to advocating for the rights of consumers in the Asia-Pacific region to access and use evidence-based, regulated, and properly marketed harm reduction products as a means of reducing the devastating impact of smoking-related diseases. 

We encourage further research, open dialogue, and collaboration with governments, health organisations, and stakeholders to ensure the best possible outcomes for public health,” it says. 


Photo Credit:

  • Photo by Dan Freeman on Unsplash

Dave Cross avatar

Dave Cross

Journalist at POTV
View Articles

Dave is a freelance writer; with articles on music, motorbikes, football, pop-science, vaping and tobacco harm reduction in Sounds, Melody Maker, UBG, AWoL, Bike, When Saturday Comes, Vape News Magazine, and syndicated across the Johnston Press group. He was published in an anthology of “Greatest Football Writing”, but still believes this was a mistake. Dave contributes sketches to comedy shows and used to co-host a radio sketch show. He’s worked with numerous vape companies to develop content for their websites.

Join the discussion