Exclusionary Tactics Criticised

Posted 5th February 2024 by Dave Cross
 Exclusionary Tactics Criticised lead image
The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA) has issued a sharp critique of the World Health Organisation's Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (WHO FCTC) for its exclusion of consumer groups and harm reduction advocates from the Tenth Session of the Conference of the Parties (COP10). The event begins today 5 February in Panama.

CAPHRA argues that this exclusionary practice is in stark contrast to the successful, pragmatic approaches of countries like New Zealand, the Philippines, and Malaysia, which have embraced vaping as a harm reduction tool,” said Nancy Loucas, a passionate advocate for tobacco harm reduction and executive coordinator of CAPHRA.

The public health policy expert condemns the WHO FCTC's COP10 meetings for silencing the voices of those who advocate for harm reduction strategies, such as vaping, which have been shown to significantly reduce smoking prevalence in countries where they are available and regulated.

CAPHRA points out that the prohibitionist approach of countries like Australia, which recently banned vaping products, is not in the best interest of public health.

“CAPHRA calls on FCTC officials to open their minds to harm reduction and to consider the evidence from countries like New Zealand, where smoking rates have decreased due to the availability of regulated vaping products,” continues Ms Loucas.

The organisation stresses the importance of including consumer groups in the decision-making process, as they provide essential insights into the needs of smokers and how alternative products can be used effectively.


Concerns raised by EU member states about being excluded from negotiations at COP10 and the need for transparency and inclusivity in discussions that impact public health.

CAPHRA's criticism aligns with reports that the WHO is influenced by special interest groups and that the FCTC has become restrictive in its engagement with NGOs, creating an echo chamber that ignores the potential benefits of harm reduction strategies.

CAPHRA urges the WHO FCTC to re-evaluate its stance on harm reduction and to engage with all stakeholders, including consumer groups, to develop effective tobacco control policies that prioritise public health and respect the Right to Health,” Ms Loucas concluded.

The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Advocates is a regional alliance of consumer tobacco harm reduction advocacy organisations. Its mission is to educate, advocate and represent the right of adult alternative nicotine consumers to access and use of products that reduce harm from tobacco use.

Harm reduction expert Clive Bates has written a Survival Guide for Delegates to the FCTC COP10.


COPWATCH will be providing ongoing commentary from the event across the week and has already started with a comprehensive guide for the COP10 week.

 Dave Cross
Article by Dave Cross
Freelance writer, salad destroyer and live culture convert.
Vape Green